Housing Market Bottom - Price-to-Rent Ratio Estimates
by:
Lawrence Roberts
Comparative rent is the primary method of evaluating the fundamental value of any property. The price-to-rent ratio links the cost of ownership with the cost of rental. This link is direct because possession of property can be obtained by either method. The cost of ownership encapsulates all of the financing terms and other variables associated with possession of real estate as does the cost of rental. Price-to-rent ratio fluctuates over time as changes in the cost of ownership and terms of financing makes financing amounts vary and house prices vary as well.
One of the major components of any projection using price-to-rent ratios is the projection of future rents. On a national level rents have been rising at a 3.6% rate from 1988 to 2007. This is 0.6% greater than the rate of inflation and 0.3% greater than the rate of wage growth. In Orange County, California, rents have been rising at the rate of 4.7% from 1983 to 2007. This is 1.7% greater than the rate of inflation and 1.3% greater than the rate of wage growth.
Any difference between the rate of rental growth and the rate of wage growth cannot be sustained forever; however, the differential on the national level is small, and it can be attributed to changing customer behavior as people demonstrate an increased willingness to spend more on housing related costs. The rate of rent growth over wage growth in Orange County is a bit more troubling. Orange County is second only to Honolulu, Hawaii as the most expensive place to rent in the United States and the continued growth of rents in excess of wages is not sustainable.
The unprecedented spike in the national price-to-rent ratio is clear evidence of a massive, national real estate bubble. As the ratio demonstrates, there was no increase in rents justifying market pricing. The only other explanation which would deny a market bubble would be a dramatic lowering of ownership costs through other means. Although lower interest rates did lower ownership costs somewhat, the resulting savings due to lower interest rates only explains about one-third to one-half of the increase in prices. The remainder is caused by the use of exotic financing and irrational exuberance.
Predictions based on the price-to-rent ratio are arguably the most robust because the ratio has been stable over long periods of time, and for good reason; the comparative cost of ownership to rental is a logical basis for valuation. If house prices return to their historic average of the 1988 to 2004 period of 181, then national prices will fall 27% peak-to-trough, bottom in 2011 and return to the peak in 2020.
The ratio of price-to-rent in Orange County, California, where the city of Irvine is located, has shown more variability than national figures. There was a coastal bubble taking off in the late 80s and collapsing in the early 1990s. The premise of prices reverting to fundamental valuations can be clearly seen in the changes in the price-to-rent ratio in Orange County. In the mid 1980s, the market was bottoming out from the first coastal residential real estate bubble associated with the inflationary times of the late 1970s. From 1983 to 1987, the price to rent ratio stabilized between 176 and 185, a range of about 6%. After the coastal bubble, prices stabilized in 1994 to 1996 in a range from 175 to 178.
Projections using the price-to-rent ratio assume prices will fall again to the range from 175 to 185 before stabilizing. The reason prices stabilize in this range is because it is here that the cost of ownership approximates the cost of rental, and Rent Savers buy real estate and form a support bottom. If house prices in Orange County return to their historic price-to-rent stability range, prices will fall 22% peak-to-trough, bottom in 2013, and return to the previous peak by 2019; however, if rental increases do not sustain their 4.7% historic rate, the bottom may be somewhat lower, and the return to the previous peak would be delayed.
Using the price-to-rent ratio is one of the most accurate predictors of the market bottom. The stability of the price-to-rent ratio is remarkable considering the variability in economic terms. The only times this ratio deviates from its tight range is when irrational exuberance takes over a market during a financial mania like the great housing bubble.
About the Author:
Lawrence Roberts is the author of The Great Housing Bubble: Why Did House Prices Fall?
Learn more and get FREE eBooks at:
http://www.thegreathousingbubble.com/
Read the author's daily dispatches at The Irvine Housing Blog:
http://www.irvinehousingblog.com/
No. of Times this article has been viewed :
183
Date Published :
Jan 1 2009
Most Recently Published Investment Management Articles as of
|
|
Mar 20 2010
Taking Your First Steps in the Investment World
by
BMA Editorial Team A
The fact that you are reading this material is a good first step, showing that you are ready to get serious about your investments. But this is just the first step.
|
Mar 20 2010
Investing: Saving Your Retirement
by
BMA Editorial Team A
It's possible to grow your money faster with less risk. It's possible to draw out more than 4% without the fear of running out of money. And it's done by adjusting conventional wisdom to the realities of the markets.
|
Mar 20 2010
Invest Smart - Establish an Emergency Fund First
by
BMA Editorial Team A
When an investor over extends himself he has very little choice but to do into his portfolio and sell stocks at a financial lost to that he has the funds available to afford and pay for immediate items. Lack of cash flow can be extremely stressful.
|
Mar 19 2010
Five Steps to a Comfortable Retirement - Without Winning the Lottery
by
BMA Editorial Team A
What does surprise me is that many Americans believe that they cannot retire comfortably unless they win the lottery. Fortunately, building a comfortable retirement nest egg is easier than you think.
|
Mar 19 2010
When is the Best Time to Start Investing?
by
BMA Editorial Team A
Of course, assuming that you haven't begun investing yet, then the answer has to be now. Unfortunately, many of us fail to understand how valuable even a few years can be in making a difference to the funds that you have earned during your investing.
|
Mar 18 2010
Investing for Your Retirement
by
BMA Editorial Team A
Of course no one likes the idea of getting old but there are several things that you can do to make sure you enjoy the later years of your life without the stress and hassle of financial concerns.
|
Mar 18 2010
The Benefits of Online Banking and Investment
by
BMA Editorial Team A
The past decade has seen a great deal of change within the business of banking. Banking the old fashion away is no longer cost efficient or effective. Today, banks are encouraging their clients to bank and invest online whenever possible. Why?
|
Mar 18 2010
Estate: How Do You Like These Odds?
by
BMA Editorial Team A
Are you a gambler? Do you like to play the odds? If you don't take action, you could needlessly cost your spouse thousands of dollars and countless headaches in order for them to make decisions on your behalf.
|
Mar 15 2010
Do You Work for Money or Send Money to Work for You
by
BMA Editorial Team A
Eventually, you will want to stop working and enjoy a retirement age. And if you have been wise and put your money to work for you, then you can often reach that time of relaxation much earlier.
|
Mar 15 2010
Basics of Investing in Life Annuities
by
BMA Editorial Team A
For investors who are new or just leery of the stock market, life annuities are a great choice. This is a way that money can be put away on a consistent basis and then it is given the ability to grow.
|
Mar 15 2010
Three Keys to Knowing If You Should Diversify
by
BMA Editorial Team A
When all is said and done choosing to diversify is based on three simple things : time, money, and desired return. There are three types of investments : bonds, mutual funds, and stocks.
|
Mar 14 2010
Long Term Value Investing with Mutual Funds
by
BMA Editorial Team A
The primary advantage of a mutual fund is that of diversification and professional management. Professional portfolio management isn't something that a majority of investors have access to so it serves as not only a safer investment but also usually a more profitable one.
|
Mar 14 2010
Should You Be Investing in Oil?
by
BMA Editorial Team A
Make sure you consider all the above points when starting to invest in oil and gas stocks. Black gold can be an extremely profitable investments but only through aggressive education and research can you find financial security.
|
Mar 10 2010
Teaching Children About Money: You Can Never Invest Too Early
by
BMA Editorial Team A
Every parent wants to make sure their children have their needs and wants filled however what are you teaching your children about the value of money and hard work. Developing money and investing skills early will help their future success.
|
Mar 10 2010
Life Insurance, A Great Investment Opportunity
by
BMA Editorial Team A
Insurance is often the safe and most risk free approach to investment.
|
|
Search for ebooks on Management & Business